Give us a call today: (832) 430-3194
andwright

CRM & Automation

Why Your Follow-Up Emails Land in Spam: SPF, DKIM and DMARC in Plain English

What SPF, DKIM and DMARC do, why Gmail and Yahoo now expect them, and what a small business should check first so follow-up emails reach the inbox.

™

andwright.com

You set up a follow-up email for new inquiries. It is friendly, useful and sent within minutes. Then a customer says, "I never got your email," and you find it later in their spam folder. Or worse, you never find out at all.

Spam filtering has many causes, but for small businesses, one of the most common is missing or broken email authentication. SPF, DKIM and DMARC sound technical, and the setup does involve DNS records, but the idea behind each one is simple. This article explains them in plain English and what to check first.

01Why this matters more now

In 2024, Gmail and Yahoo both tightened their requirements for people sending email to their users. Google's email sender guidelines say that, starting February 1, 2024, all senders to personal Gmail accounts must set up SPF or DKIM, keep spam complaint rates reported in Postmaster Tools below 0.3%, and meet other technical requirements.

Senders of more than 5,000 messages a day to Gmail accounts must set up SPF, DKIM and DMARC, and support one-click unsubscribe for marketing messages. Yahoo publishes similar sender best practices.

Most small businesses do not send 5,000 emails a day. But your CRM, newsletter tool and booking system may each send on your behalf, and they all need to be set up correctly so mailbox providers can tell your email is really from you.

02SPF: who is allowed to send for your domain

SPF, which stands for Sender Policy Framework, is a DNS record on your domain that lists the services allowed to send email using your domain name. Think of it as a guest list. If your business email is with Google Workspace, and you also send through a CRM and a newsletter tool, all three should be on the list.

The common problem is that a business adds a new tool and forgets to update SPF. Emails from that tool then fail the check. Another problem is having two separate SPF records, which can cause failures; there should be one SPF record that includes every sender.

03DKIM: a signature that proves the email was not altered

DKIM, short for DomainKeys Identified Mail, adds a digital signature to each email. Your email service signs outgoing messages, and you publish a matching public key in your DNS. Receiving mail servers check the signature to confirm the message came from an authorized sender and was not changed in transit.

Each sending service has its own DKIM setup. Google Workspace has one. Your CRM has one. Your newsletter tool has one. If you set up DKIM for your main email but not for your CRM, emails from the CRM may still look unauthenticated.

04DMARC: what to do when a check fails

DMARC, short for Domain-based Message Authentication, Reporting and Conformance, is a DNS record that tells receiving servers what to do with email that fails SPF and DKIM alignment checks, and where to send reports about it.

You can start with a policy of "none," which asks for reports without changing delivery. Google's guidelines note that a DMARC policy of none is acceptable for bulk senders.

Over time, once you are sure all your legitimate senders pass, you can move to stricter policies that ask receivers to quarantine or reject failing mail. That protects your domain from being spoofed by others.

05What to check first

  1. List every tool that sends email as your domain. Your main email, your CRM, booking software, invoicing, newsletter, website forms. Many businesses are surprised by how many there are.
  2. Check each tool's domain authentication settings. Most have a page that shows whether SPF and DKIM are verified for your domain.
  3. Look at your DNS records. Confirm there is one SPF record that includes all your senders, DKIM records for each service, and a DMARC record.
  4. Send a test to a personal Gmail address. Open the message, choose "Show original," and look for SPF, DKIM and DMARC results.

If you are not comfortable editing DNS, ask whoever manages your domain or website to help. A wrong change can break email, so make one change at a time and test.

06Authentication is necessary, not sufficient

Passing SPF, DKIM and DMARC does not guarantee the inbox. Mailbox providers also watch how people respond to your email. A few habits help:

  • Send to people who asked to hear from you. Do not buy lists.
  • Use a real reply-to address. Replies are a good sign; a no-reply address gives people only the spam button.
  • Make unsubscribing easy. CAN-SPAM rules (see 16 CFR Part 316) require commercial emails to include an opt-out, and it is better for someone to unsubscribe than to mark you as spam.
  • Keep follow-up emails plain and relevant. A short, personal message about the customer's request usually performs better than a heavy, image-filled template.
  • Watch your volume. A sudden jump from a few emails to thousands can trigger filtering.

07Where this fits in follow-up

Email is only one channel. For time-sensitive follow-up, such as a new inquiry or a missed call, a text is often faster. For longer nurture, such as a welcome sequence or a quote reminder, email works well, as long as it arrives. Fixing authentication is one of the least glamorous parts of follow-up, and one of the most important.

If you are setting up email follow-up for the first time, A Welcome Email Sequence for Course Creators shows what a short sequence can look like, and How Many Times Should You Follow Up? covers pacing.

Want your follow-up emails authenticated and tested?

andwright sets up email domains, authentication and follow-up sequences inside the CRM, then tests delivery before anything goes live. Book a strategy call if you want that checked.

Book a strategy call